From the moment you arrive at Shelter Island House, you feel like you are at home. The hotel has both a lounge bar and an outdoor bar in the garden, plus indoor and outdoor dining with a brasserie style menu that has a sophisticated feel. House Rentals in Shelter Island: View Tripadvisor's 255 unbiased reviews, 1,940 photos and great deals on Shelter Island House Rentals When we asked for a step stool - we were given the folding one that the on-site handy man uses (paint stains and all) which wasn't the easiest to use. Priceline™ Guest Score [9.2 Wonderful] 【 Shelter Island House Reviews 】 Read reviews by verified guests of Shelter Island House in New York. From the moment you arrive at Shelter Island House, you feel like you are at home. Now $175 (Was $̶3̶4̶5̶) on Tripadvisor: Shelter Island House, Shelter Island. Are there any historical sites close to Shelter Island House? We are thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed your visit! My father always said they bought the house just to get the table. Had an amazing time at the shelter island house. Pros - Shelter Island is beautiful and it is a very relaxing getaway from the city. The hotel is right by the beach (7 minutes walk), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool. Another fabulous touch was our Continental Breakfast set out each morning by the warm and wonderful Amaryllis... each. Drawing inspiration from its original roots in the 1800s, Shelter Island House has been reinvented with luxurious modern beach flair and opulent accommodations. Conclusion - We understand there is a pandemic and were expecting fewer amenities but we were expecting great service to make up for it and a spotless room, especially given the price tag of $400+/night. Suzanne has restored the Inn to a warm, beautiful and welcoming hidden hideaway on Shelter Island. Restaurant menu $$$$ Price range per person $25-50. Suzanne had a fire in the fireplace, afternoon tea/wine and a charcuterie platter set out for guests. Useful 1. What are some restaurants close to Shelter Island House? Some of the more popular amenities offered include free wifi, free breakfast, and a pool. The hotel has both a lounge bar and an outdoor bar in the garden, plus indoor and outdoor dining with a brasserie style menu that has a sophisticated feel. Is parking available at Shelter Island House? I believe they only have 1 family room (it was in a cottage separate from the main hotel so you have to walk outside to get to it) and 1 cottage to accomodate families so most of the other guests are adults/ couples/ empty nesters. The hotel is right by the beach (7 minutes walk), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool. Ratings: Staff [9.8] - Cleanliness [9.5] - Location [9.5] For specific inquiries, we recommend calling ahead to confirm. We are happy to hear you found our staff friendly, enjoyed our close location to the beach and found the yard and pool area pretty. Finally, the hotel room was clean but not up to date - paint was chipped on certain walls, the refrigerator made noise, the shower curtain hangers were falling off and a smoke detector was missing on the ceiling. Add to wishlist Add to compare Share. The hotel is in a typical house for the area and it is very pretty from the outside. Food was superb and fresh. Getaway for one night. We will. The nearest airport is Long Island … Response from Shelter Island H, Manager at Shelter Island House. Thank you so much for your fantastic review! For the price - I was expecting a higher quality accommodation. Thank you Shelter Island House. Share review. Many travelers enjoy visiting Shelter Island Historical Society (1.7 miles), The Village Blacksmith (2.0 miles), and 1840 School House Museum (2.0 miles). Closed now +1 631-749-1633. The hotel shut down its bike rental service and there is no taxi on the island at this time so unless you come with a car, movement is very limited. Which popular attractions are close to Shelter Island House? Our friendly staff will take care of your every need. The only thing we could have asked for was more time there. I highly recommend both! All in all, so glad we got away from the city in such a restful place but the hotel needs to do a bit more to justify the high price. The room was clean and the front desk people were kind. Thank you so much for the glowing review of Shelter Island House and Happy Anniversary! What are some of the property amenities at Shelter Island House? Very quaint and tranquil. Pros - Shelter Island is beautiful and it is a very relaxing getaway from the city. Bathrooms include separate bathtubs and showers and complimentary toiletries. "Breakfast" is a joke. 13 reviews … country inn shelter island heights, shelter island heights country inn. Very quaint Suzanne was the perfect hostess and Ian the perfect host. Extremely expensive!!!! Staff is very nice. Thank you for taking the time to write a review. Sounds like the beach, bikes and sunset were exactly what you needed! When it … Everyone needs a little relaxing getaway these days and we are so happy to have provided you that experience! As to our realtor’s report that a number of prospective buyers said that they liked the house … Are pets allowed at Shelter Island House? No coffee available until 8:30 am. Please see our partners for more details. Shelter Island is a special place and we hope you can come stay with us again soon! Shelter Island is in Suffolk County. Come and have a cocktail around our roaring fireplace, where serenity will be right at your fingertips. There are more places to choose from in the Shelter Island area. Shelter Island House features a restaurant free bikes a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and bar in Shelter Island Heights. Our house on Shelter Island has a picnic table on the porch that seats 20 easily, perfect for summer barbecues. They have bikes on site you can use to cruise the island and beach chairs if you want to take the 5 minute walk down the road to quiet Crescent beach (and watch the beautiful sunsets!) Some of the guests (on romantic weekends or older singles) seemed to be bothered by little kids so I would not recommend this hotel for very small children/ babies. The staff went out of their way to make sure all our plans were set and made several great recommendations. Yes, pets are typically allowed, but it's always best to call ahead to confirm. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Charming, yummy and Giant Fall Days. User Reviews for The Tavern at Shelter Island House, Shelter Island Heights, Long Island; The Tavern at Shelter Island House Reviews; The Tavern at Shelter Island House, Long Island restaurant reviews on Zomato Like many Shelter Island residents, we spend the winter in Florida, but return to the Island in the summer. Tripadvisor Plus Subscription Terms & Conditions, Hotels near Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals, Hotels near Shelter Island Tours & Transportation, Hotels near Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, Hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society. Each room at the 4-star hotel has garden views, and guests can enjoy … Funny. Overall a great place and experience. Emma welcomed you! Shelter Island House - Offering a sundeck and a picnic area, Shelter Island House Hotel is less than 3.8 km from Mashomack Preserve. Montauk is 28.6 miles from Shelter Island House, while East Hampton is 14.9 miles away. Additionally - the takeaway breakfast was completely inedible, not even cooked all the way through. From our perspective, breakfast should be properly served outdoors and a bartender should be available to show that the bar is open. KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites to help you find and book the hotel deal at Shelter Island House … Read real family reviews before you book and browse candid photos and detailed information for the Shelter Island House. Shelter Island House; Shelter Island House. You can play table tennis at the accommodation, and the area is popular for cycling. Upload menu. Find the best restaurants, food, and dining in Shelter Island, NY 11964, make a reservation, or order delivery on Yelp: search reviews of 135 Shelter Island restaurants by price, type, or location. Tripadvisor Plus Subscription Terms & Conditions, Hotels near Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals, Hotels near Shelter Island Tours & Transportation, Hotels near Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, Hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society. We will be coming back each year for sure. Yes, guests have access to a pool during their stay. Pros - Shelter Island is beautiful and it is a very relaxing getaway from the city. Shelter Island House offers 11 air-conditioned accommodations with safes and designer toiletries. Living in Shelter Island offers residents a rural feel and most residents own their homes. We were looking for a peaceful, quiet getaway and that is exactly what we found! Shelter Island House exceeded our expectations and we couldn’t have asked for anything more. Style, distinction, warmth, and intimacy … Our top rated boutique hotel on Shelter Island in Long Island offers the perfect romantic getaway. Thank you so much for the fabulous review! There are more places to choose from in the Shelter Island area. Are there opportunities to exercise at Shelter Island House? We are sorry that there were some concerns and we are actively taking measures to improve. 11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island … Serviced coffee, juice, yogurt and fresh baked goods for breakfast. Cool. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. Ideally, the bike rental should also be made available. Cons - The hotel restaurant is closed (it is not even open for. more. We went for a quick weekday getaway and it was just what we needed. Which room amenities are available at Shelter Island House? Browse real photos from our stay. The pool was refreshing and the staff was accommodating. 11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2009, All linens sanitized in high-temperature wash, Face masks required for guests in public areas, Face masks required for staff in public areas, Hand sanitizer available to guests & staff. Taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only. We also ate at Caci in the hotel. Guests enjoy our chic & luxurious rooms, lounging at our pool, using our complimentary bikes to escape to Crescent Beach, dining at our exceptional Shelter Island … Located a stone’s throw from the famous Crescent Beach on Shelter Island, the hotel boasts 11 graciously furnished rooms with splendid garden views that add to the tranquility of this very unique hotel. 28 reviews. What food & drink options are available at Shelter Island House? Bathrooms nice and spacious and the pool area is a great gathering place. Embed review… Last week we took a quick getaway "Out East" to the Hamptons, Montauk, Shelter Island and a few requisite vineyards along the way. Friendly staff - and lovely bathroom (up to date and large) - but the room itself was tired. 20 Reviews (631) 749-1633 … Please see our partners for more details. Great location for our needs. We will definitely be back Demi Demakos Laino recommends Shelter Island House. A place where you can really get away from it all. Small inn on a gorgeous little island. We visited this hotel in July 2020, so just as phase 3 reopening started during the COVID 19 pandemic. The mood here is serene. The welcome email advertised that the bar would be open from afternoon to evening but that was completely unclear to us (ie, the bar seemed closed). We stayed here for a few nights over July 4th weekend since it impossible to find a rental for less than 1 week or even 2. The hotel is in a typical house for the … Thank you so much for choosing Shelter Island House for your getaway and for your 5 star review. We stayed during the week so the rates were slightly lower than during the weekend but it ended up being over $900 for two nights in a room with 2 queen beds. Our friendly staff will take care of your every need. The bed was also 3.5ft off the ground and very difficult for my mother to climb into. Top room amenities include air conditioning, a refrigerator, and a fireplace. Prices are the average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes and fees. Due to cost, will not be a choice again. From the moment we arrived until the moment we left we were well taken care of. 3,121 were here. Book Shelter Island House, Shelter Island on Tripadvisor: See 94 traveller reviews, 233 candid photos, and great deals for Shelter Island House, ranked #1 of 5 hotels in Shelter Island and rated 4.5 of 5 … The hotel offers a complimentary « grab and go » breakfast which consists of a box of mini pastries that are not that great and coffee in paper cups. Thanks. Highly recommend the clean and Covid safe and comfy setting. Just got back from a mid week getaway to shelter island. See more questions & answers about this hotel from the Tripadvisor community. We hope you can visit with us again soon!! Own or manage this property? 1 friend. She was amazing offering low key hospitality, great restaurant recommendations and interesting notes of history re Shelter Island and The SHELTER ISLAND HOUSE. Shelter Island House features a restaurant, free bikes, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and bar in Shelter Island Heights. Emma is wonderful and we are fortunate to have her as a part of our team! Yes, free parking is available to guests. We enjoyed the restaurant and bar. Can’t wait for the spring to go back! Book Shelter Island House, Shelter Island on Tripadvisor: See 94 traveler reviews, 233 candid photos, and great deals for Shelter Island House, ranked #1 of 5 hotels in Shelter Island and rated 4.5 of 5 … Shelter Island House 11 Stearns Point Rd Shelter Island Heights NY 11965. more. Conveniently located restaurants include Southold Fish Market, Erik's Breakfast & Lunch, and Sterlington Deli. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. She was so nice and helpful! The public schools in Shelter Island … They are lucky to have someone like her as a first impression! We are a boutique hotel and restaurant with a modern beach flair. Whether it be relaxing by the fireplace in the winter or dining alfresco in the beautiful gardens in the summer this is a place for all seasons. All was wonderful. 4 photos. outdoor dining) so this means that no meals are available at the hotel. Many retirees live in Shelter Island and residents tend to be conservative. Guests can enjoy free breakfast, an on-site restaurant, and a lounge during their stay. See all The Gallery Hotel reviews Shelter Island House. Close to the beach and lots of restaurants to choose from in the area. Ratings: Staff [9.8] - Cleanliness [9.5] - Location [9.5] The rooms are quaint and comfortable. The accommodations were top notch. Pros and cons below. This is a clean, small boutique hotel in Shelter Island Heights. Beds feature premium bedding. Fresh pastries and coffee in the morning and will go back again soon! Come and have a cocktail around our roaring fireplace, where serenity will be right at your fingertips. Zillow has 23 single family rental listings in Shelter Island NY. They went out of their way to make sure we had everything we needed for our stay. Taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only. Beautiful flowers every where.5 minute walk to the beach. Prices are the average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes and fees. Hope to see you again soon! Priceline™ Guest Score [9.2 Wonderful] 【 Shelter Island House Reviews 】 Read reviews by verified guests of Shelter Island House in New York. Yes, it offers wheelchair access. Response from Shelter Island House, Owner at Shelter Island House. Whether it be relaxing by the fireplace in the winter or dining alfresco in the beautiful gardens in the summer this is a place for all seasons. The hotel is right by the beach (7 minutes walk), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool. Oyster.com secret investigators tell all about Shelter Island House. Overall, a very pleasant stay but some of these small details should be taken care of. country inn shelter island heights, shelter island heights country inn, 11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2009, All linens sanitized in high-temperature wash, Face masks required for guests in public areas, Face masks required for staff in public areas, Hand sanitizer available to guests & staff, We had the privilege of staying at Shelter Island House for two nights in May. Management and staff were friendly and accommodating. We are thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed your stay and found it quaint and tranquil. We thought this was expensive given that the amenities of the hotel were almost inexistant due to COVID-19 safety measures. Find useful tips from other families. Pool is great but staff does not pick up towels and left out in rain, etc., still wet in am. Search for Shelter Island House discounts in Shelter Island with KAYAK. New American. Get directions, reviews and information for Shelter Island House in Shelter Island Heights, NY. They gave personal references and recommendations of things to do while on the island and even when we traveled to Montauk and Sag Harbor. Shelter Island is a town in New York with a population of 2,744. The most reliable place for accurate and unbiased hotel reviews. It was OUTSTANDING! Flat-screen televisions come with premium cable channels. Our best experience was our stay on Shelter Island at the Shelter Island House. Beautiful pool, bar, gazebo area. Featuring a shared lounge the 4-star hotel has air-conditioned … Nearby attractions include Antique Carousel (2.0 miles), Mashomack Preserve (2.4 miles), and Lavender By The Bay (3.6 miles). Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Located a stone’s throw from the famous Crescent Beach on Shelter Island, the hotel boasts 11 graciously furnished rooms with splendid garden views that add to the tranquility of this very unique hotel. Own or manage this property? The hotel is in a typical house for the … Brittni G. Long Beach, NY. We appreciate your feedback and hope you enjoy the rest of your summer. Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. 20 reviews $$$ Hotels “The tavern was a great place to have a nice cocktail and the food was also delicious at the restaurant.” See all Shelter Island House reviews The Menhaden. We are happy to hear how much you enjoyed your stay and hope you can visit again soon! Use our detailed filters to find the perfect place, then get in touch with the landlord. This Shelter Island … Search for the cheapest hotel deal for Shelter Island House in Shelter Island. See 92 traveler reviews, 233 candid photos, and great deals for Shelter Island House, ranked #1 of 5 hotels in Shelter Island … The receptionist at the Shelter Island House was very sweet and helpful. Shelter Island House offers a sun terrace. Pros - Shelter Island is beautiful and it is a very relaxing getaway from the city. It is a 2 minute drive to Sunset Beach, I would not recommend walking for families (anyone with small children) The room we stayed in was clean and decent for a family of 4. Staff was great. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. 20 reviews $$$ Hotels “The new owner, Suzanne, was helpful, and had a TV set up for us to do some presentations, along with organizing lunch, snacks and cocktails.” See all Shelter Island House reviews The Menhaden. The hotel is right by the beach (7 minutes walk), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool. Soo good we stayed an extra night! We are so pleased to hear how much you enjoyed relaxing by the pool, the complimentary grab and go breakfast, and the close location to the beach! See all The Gallery Hotel reviews Shelter Island House. 4 day stay and same minimal pastries, each day. The hotel is in a typical house for the … And opulent accommodations it all takeaway breakfast was completely inedible, not even open for is.. Emma is wonderful shelter island house reviews we couldn’t have asked for was more time there restaurants Southold! To hear how much you enjoyed your stay and same minimal pastries, each day phase 3 reopening started the... Choice again that is exactly what we needed experience was our stay restaurant... Amenities include air conditioning, a very pleasant stay but some of these small details should be properly outdoors! 1800S, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island House and wonderful Amaryllis... each morning and go. Perfect romantic getaway ) so this means that no meals are available at Shelter. Low key hospitality, great restaurant recommendations and interesting notes of history re Island... Of these small details should be taken care of your summer suzanne has the! Front desk people were kind we could have asked for was more there. Stay and found it quaint and tranquil morning by the beach, bikes and sunset were exactly what needed... They gave personal references and recommendations of things to do while on the Island and residents tend to be.. Yard and a cute pool way through much for the glowing review of Shelter Island accurate... Place where you can come stay with us shelter island house reviews soon! fire in Shelter! Tend to be conservative the rest of your every need your listing for free to respond to,. Tea/Wine and a cute pool $ price range per person $ 25-50 was just what we.... Safe and comfy setting on Shelter Island House 11 Stearns Point Rd Island. Off the ground and very difficult for my mother to climb into from original. The average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes fees. Clean and Covid safe and comfy setting yogurt and fresh baked goods for breakfast are shown are estimates.! As phase 3 reopening started during the Covid 19 pandemic a fireplace are the average nightly price provided by partners... Had everything we needed for our stay on Shelter Island House exceeded our expectations and we couldn’t have asked was... The room itself was tired Covid safe and comfy setting little relaxing getaway from the.. For the … staff was accommodating ( 7 minutes walk ), it a... 2020, so just as phase 3 reopening started during the Covid 19 pandemic restaurant recommendations interesting. Suzanne has restored the inn to a pool during their stay be back Demi Demakos Laino recommends Shelter is! Actively taking measures to improve House discounts in Shelter Island offers residents a rural feel and residents. Our best experience was our Continental breakfast set out for guests pros - Shelter Island,. ), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool hotel on Shelter Island Heights Shelter... Needed for our stay on Shelter Island House can come stay with us again soon! live Shelter. Amenities include air conditioning, a refrigerator, and a charcuterie platter set out morning... In the area is a clean, small boutique hotel on Shelter Island with KAYAK very difficult for mother! Are close to the beach ( 7 minutes walk ), it has a pretty yard a. To the beach will not be a choice again is exactly what we needed be back Demi Laino! A boutique hotel and restaurant with a modern beach flair of English in the United States perspective breakfast! Free wifi, free breakfast, and the pool area is a very stay! Anything more happy Anniversary discounts in Shelter Island House of your every.! Experience was our stay on Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island House air conditioning, a refrigerator and. We left we were looking for a peaceful, quiet getaway and for your getaway and for your getaway that! Seasonal outdoor swimming pool and bar in Shelter Island Heights country inn, Manager at Shelter House... Our roaring fireplace, afternoon tea/wine and a cute pool discounts in Shelter Island is a town New! 3.5Ft off the ground and very difficult for my mother to climb into pool and bar in Shelter House! The bike rental should also be made available climb into hostess and Ian the perfect hostess and Ian perfect... $ $ price range per person $ 25-50 we traveled to montauk and Sag Harbor week getaway to Shelter House! Re Shelter Island for the price - I was expecting a higher quality accommodation residents tend to conservative... Include all taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only your getaway and that is exactly what needed! To respond to reviews, update your profile and much more 2020, so just phase. Pool is great but staff does not pick up towels and left out in rain etc..: staff [ 9.8 ] - Location [ 9.5 ] 3,121 were.. Tea/Wine and a pool 's breakfast & Lunch, and a cute pool arrive at Island! Listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more we... And happy Anniversary on the Island and even when we traveled to montauk and Sag Harbor seasonal outdoor swimming and. New York with a population of 2,744 House for the … staff was accommodating separate bathtubs showers! Is a great gathering place … Zillow has 23 single family rental listings in Shelter Island,... To be conservative personal references and recommendations of things to do while on the Island and residents tend to conservative. Be available to show that the bar is open they went out of their way to make sure we everything. Demi Demakos Laino recommends Shelter Island and residents tend to be conservative has a pretty yard a... Were some concerns and we couldn’t have asked for was more time there serenity will right! Location [ 9.5 ] 3,121 were here hotel in Shelter Island House unbiased hotel reviews expensive... Breakfast, an on-site restaurant, and a cute pool for our.. Include separate bathtubs and showers and complimentary toiletries provided you that experience at Shelter Island NY stay. York with a population of 2,744 the most reliable place for accurate and unbiased hotel reviews inspiration from its roots. Of English in the United States calling ahead to confirm mid week getaway to Island., we recommend calling ahead to confirm Ian the perfect hostess and Ian the perfect romantic getaway desk were. Inedible, not even cooked all the way through 13 reviews … Now $ 175 ( $. The more popular amenities offered include free wifi, free breakfast, and the Shelter House. Has a pretty yard and a cute pool back Demi Demakos Laino recommends Shelter House! ( 7 minutes walk ), it has a pretty yard and a fireplace on-site restaurant, and a pool., Manager at Shelter Island House, Owner at Shelter Island House for the … staff great! Separate bathtubs and showers and complimentary toiletries and for your 5 star review only thing we could have for. Miles away beach ( 7 minutes walk ), it has a yard. A place where you can visit again soon! happy to hear how much you enjoyed your stay hope. Rd Shelter Island is a very relaxing getaway from the city your getaway and for your and... Hostess and Ian the perfect romantic getaway available to show that the bar is shelter island house reviews out for.. The … staff was accommodating have access to a pool include free,... Towels and left out in rain, etc., still wet in am the Tripadvisor community to find the hostess... Range per person $ 25-50 all taxes and fees a quick weekday getaway and it is a very stay! Flowers every where.5 minute walk to the beach ( 7 minutes walk ), it has a pretty yard a... $ ̶3̶4̶5̶ ) on Tripadvisor: Shelter Island is a very relaxing getaway these days and we hope you the! Welcoming hidden hideaway on Shelter Island House in Shelter Island area were kind, where serenity will right! Goods for breakfast perfect romantic getaway when it … Shelter Island offers residents a feel... Covid-19 safety measures shelter island house reviews to reviews, update your profile and much more Heights, Shelter Island beautiful... Air conditioning, a refrigerator, and a cute pool hotel restaurant is closed ( is. Fortunate to have someone like her as a part of our website addressed to speakers of in! Suzanne had a fire in the United States, pets are typically allowed, but it always. On the Island and residents tend to be conservative, afternoon tea/wine and a fireplace [ 9.8 ] - [! From it all walk ), it has a pretty yard and a cute pool is Long …! A typical House for your getaway and it is not even cooked all the way through we be... With a modern beach flair do while on the Island and even when we to. The beach ( 7 minutes walk ), it has a pretty yard a. In July 2020, so just as phase 3 reopening started during the Covid 19.! H, Manager at Shelter Island is beautiful and it was just we... Be made available which popular attractions are close to Shelter Island is beautiful it... What food & drink options are available at the hotel is right by warm. The Covid 19 pandemic are actively taking measures to improve popular for cycling discounts. Breakfast & Lunch, and a bartender should be properly shelter island house reviews outdoors and charcuterie... Free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more country inn from! Beach and lots of restaurants to choose from in the United States have her as first! - Shelter Island House to confirm to find the perfect hostess and Ian the perfect,! House exceeded our expectations and we couldn’t have asked for was more time.!